Choose PPC when you need controllable visibility soon, invest in SEO when you want organic growth that compounds, and run both when you need short-term leads and long-term scale. Google handles almost 94% of searches in Australia, so both channels live on one platform. Ads can start within days, while SEO usually takes months. Both are subject to ACCC truthfulness rules.
TL;DR:
- Run a focused PPC test for a few weeks, tracking leads rather than clicks, then build SEO around the keywords and landing pages that convert.
- SEO can take months to lift traffic; review rankings and impressions monthly, while checking PPC spend and cost per lead weekly.
- Keep every ad and page claim accurate, specific, and provable: the ACCC penalized Employsure $1 million for Google Ads that implied government affiliation.
- For local campaigns, restrict PPC targeting to service areas and avoid duplicate location pages; national campaigns may need separate country pages, currencies, and budgets.
Table of Contents
- What is SEO and how does it deliver value?
- What is PPC and how does it deliver value?
- How do SEO and PPC compare on speed, cost, targeting and risk?
- When should you prioritise SEO, PPC or both?
- How do you combine SEO and PPC and measure combined ROI?
- How we run SEO and Google Ads together
- How do keyword intent targeting differences affect SEO and PPC?
- How do SEO and PPC affect brand visibility and credibility?
- What role do SEO and PPC play in the marketing funnel?
- How do SEO and PPC work with your other marketing channels?
- How do local and global targeting change SEO and PPC?
- What common mistakes should you avoid with SEO and PPC?
- Why PPC should be your SEO research tool
- Get a team that runs SEO and Google Ads as one plan
- FAQ
- Sources
What is SEO and how does it deliver value?
SEO is the work of improving your website so it shows up more often in unpaid search results. Government guidance on improving search rankings treats it as a continuous process, because search engines keep changing how they rank pages. You do not finish SEO. You maintain it.
The value comes from compounding. A page that ranks well keeps bringing visitors without a fee for each click, so the cost per lead tends to fall as your content and authority grow. Our work usually covers these areas:
- Technical SEO: site speed, mobile-friendly design, clean structure and crawlable pages.
- Content creation: pages and articles that answer the questions your customers actually search.
- Keyword strategy: choosing the phrases worth chasing and mapping each to one page.
- Backlink acquisition: earning links from reputable sites that signal trust to search engines.
- Ongoing maintenance: refreshing older content, fixing errors and tracking rankings.
Timelines matter here. Expect months, not weeks, before you see a material lift in traffic. Because search engines reward sustained effort, a stop-start approach tends to waste the early investment.
The cost shape is also different from paid ads. With SEO you pay for labour and production: strategy, writing, development and outreach. You do not pay the platform per click. For a rough view of what budgets buy, see our SEO pricing guide, and if you plan to do some of the work yourself, our shortlist of SEO tools covers what to use.
Pro Tip: Start with the pages that already earn impressions but sit on page two. Improving existing pages often moves faster than publishing new ones.
What is PPC and how does it deliver value?
PPC means pay-per-click advertising. You bid for placement in search results, and you are charged when someone clicks your ad. Business Victoria’s starter guide to paid search explains that Google Ads lets you pay to appear in results and that you pay only when a user clicks. Given Google’s share of Australian searches, it recommends focusing paid search on Google.
The appeal is control. You choose the keywords, the budget, the location and the message, and you can pause or change any of them the same day. Google describes several campaign types, including Search, Performance Max, Shopping and Display. Performance Max uses automation to find customers across Google’s surfaces.
A working campaign has a few moving parts:
- Keywords: the searches you want your ads to appear for, plus negative keywords to filter out wasted clicks.
- Bids and budget: what you will pay per click and the daily spend you will tolerate.
- Ad copy: the headline and description that earn the click.
- Landing pages: the page a click lands on, which decides whether the visit becomes a lead.
- Campaign type: Search for high-intent queries, Performance Max for broader automated reach.
Impressions and clicks can begin as soon as a campaign is live, but good results need optimisation. Early weeks are for learning which queries convert. Costs depend on competition for your keywords, your ad quality and how well your landing page converts. Our Google Ads management pricing guide covers typical cost shapes.
Ads must also be honest. The ACCC took action over misleading search ads in its case against Employsure, which we cover in the comparison below.
Almost 94% of searches in Australia happen on Google, according to Business Victoria. That makes Google Ads the default home for paid search.
How do SEO and PPC compare on speed, cost, targeting and risk?
The two channels solve different problems. PPC rents attention, and SEO builds an asset. Here is how they compare on the factors that matter when you are choosing where the next dollar goes.
Speed to first result. PPC can put you in front of searchers within days of launch. SEO usually takes months before it produces a meaningful lift. If a slow quarter is threatening cash flow, only PPC answers that quickly.
Cost structure. PPC cost scales with clicks, so traffic stops the moment you stop paying. SEO costs sit in labour and content, and the traffic it earns keeps arriving after the work is done, though it needs maintenance. Business.gov.au’s digital strategy advice suggests including both SEO and paid advertising in a plan, which reflects that each carries a different commitment.
Targeting and testing. PPC lets you test fast. You can change a headline, a keyword or a landing page and read the result within days. SEO tests are slower and noisier, because rankings move gradually and many factors shift at once.
Measurement. PPC reporting is direct: spend, clicks, conversions. SEO attribution is harder, because organic visitors often arrive after several touches and may convert through another channel.
Use this checklist when you weigh the trade-offs:
- Urgency: need leads this month? Lean PPC.
- Longevity: want traffic that outlasts a budget? Lean SEO.
- Testing appetite: want fast answers on what sells? Lean PPC.
- Content capacity: can you produce quality pages steadily? Lean SEO.
Follow this order when you make the call:
- Write down the revenue you need and by when.
- Check how much qualified search demand exists for your offer.
- Estimate what a lead is worth over the customer’s lifetime.
- Pick the channel that fits the timeline, then add the second when budget allows.
Compliance is a real risk on the paid side. The ACCC has penalised Employsure $1 million for misleading Google Ads, and the Full Federal Court found those ads misleading because they implied a government affiliation. The ACCC’s guidance on false or misleading claims says claims must be accurate, specific and provable, which applies to your organic copy as much as your ads.
There is also a market-structure point. The ACCC’s digital advertising services inquiry notes Google’s dominant role in ad technology, and that market dynamics shape the availability and cost of placements. Your cost per click is not entirely in your hands.
When should you prioritise SEO, PPC or both?
Start with your situation, not with a preference. Five questions settle most decisions:
- Urgency: how soon do you need enquiries?
- Customer lifetime value: can you afford to pay for clicks while you learn?
- Budget: is there room to fund both, or only one?
- Sales cycle: do buyers decide in a day, or research for months?
- Current organic presence: do you already rank for anything useful?
PPC usually wins when the offer is time-sensitive, such as a new launch, a seasonal service or an emergency trade where people search and buy the same day. It also suits businesses with no organic presence yet that need leads while the website matures.
SEO tends to win where buyers research before they commit: professional services, high-value B2B work and anything with a long sales cycle. If a customer is worth thousands of dollars over time, the compounding nature of organic traffic pays back the slower start.
A simple start, test, scale approach keeps risk low:
- Start: launch a tight PPC campaign on your most valuable commercial keywords, and fix the technical basics of your site.
- Test: run it for a few weeks and note which queries and landing pages produce leads, not just clicks.
- Scale: put the proven keywords into your SEO plan and expand paid spend only where the numbers hold up.
As a rule of thumb, judge PPC on cost per lead within the first couple of months, and judge SEO on direction of travel across several months, such as rising impressions and rankings, before expecting a big traffic jump.
This is the cheapest way to avoid a bad SEO bet. Practitioners commonly use PPC data to identify high-converting keywords and landing pages, then feed those learnings into the organic content plan. Government and official business resources also recommend a balanced approach: PPC for immediate, scalable visibility and SEO for sustainable organic presence.
Pro Tip: Before you commission a big SEO content push, spend some ad budget on the target keywords. If they do not convert as paid traffic, they are unlikely to convert as organic traffic.
How do you combine SEO and PPC and measure combined ROI?
The channels work best when they share what they learn. Treat paid search as your fast experiment and organic as your long-term build.
Follow these steps to run them together:
- Set up conversion tracking first, so every form, call and purchase is recorded.
- Use consistent UTM tags on every paid link, so reports separate sources cleanly.
- Launch PPC on your priority keywords and record which ads and landing pages convert.
- Move the winning phrases and page layouts into your SEO content plan.
- Review organic rankings monthly and reduce paid bids on terms where you already rank at the top and convert well.
- Reinvest the savings into new keywords or retargeting.
Your tracking setup should include:
- Conversion tracking: goals set up in Google Ads and your analytics tool for every lead action.
- UTM conventions: one naming scheme for source, medium and campaign, written down and used by everyone.
- A shared dashboard: paid and organic leads side by side, so you compare cost per lead honestly.
- Call tracking: if phone enquiries matter, record where they came from.
Report on different clocks. For PPC, review weekly or fortnightly: spend, click-through rate, cost per lead and conversion rate. For SEO, review monthly or quarterly: impressions, rankings for target terms, organic leads and the pages driving them. Judging SEO on weekly numbers leads to premature panic, and judging PPC monthly lets waste build up.
For budget, a phased approach works well. Fund PPC more heavily in the early months while organic work builds, then shift weight toward SEO as organic leads grow and paid costs level out. Keep a smaller paid budget running for terms where competitors still crowd the results. Our Google Ads lead generation guide shows how to turn paid clicks into enquiries.
How we run SEO and Google Ads together
We offer SEO and Google Ads management as part of our marketing services, and we run them as one programme rather than two separate ones. Our work for local business owners sits alongside our broader coaching and marketing support.
Our process, at a high level, looks like this:
- Audit: we review your site, tracking and current search presence.
- PPC test: we launch focused campaigns to learn which keywords and pages convert.
- SEO build: we use those findings to prioritise content and technical work.
- Measure: we report paid and organic results together, so you see one picture.
We work as an extension of your team and focus on measurable outcomes like qualified leads rather than vanity metrics. We cannot promise a particular ranking or result, because search engines and auction costs move. We make decisions based on your data. You can read more on our SEO and Google Ads pages.
How do keyword intent targeting differences affect SEO and PPC?
Search intent is the reason behind a query, and the two channels handle it differently. People searching “what is a good CRM” want information. People searching “CRM software pricing” are comparing options. People searching “buy CRM software Melbourne” are ready to act.
PPC lets you pick exactly which intent you pay for. Most advertisers concentrate on commercial and transactional queries, because every click costs money, and they use negative keywords to block researchers who are unlikely to buy. You are buying a narrow slice of demand, chosen on purpose.
SEO works the other way. You cannot choose your visitors click by click, so you build pages matched to each intent stage. An informational guide earns early-stage visitors. A comparison page serves the evaluators. A service page captures the ready-to-buy searcher. A single page trying to do all three usually ranks poorly for each.
Business Queensland recommends using keywords in your content and refreshing it regularly, which supports building pages around specific intents rather than one generic homepage.
A practical split is to let PPC handle high-intent terms where the click value justifies the cost, and let SEO cover the broader informational and comparison searches that would be expensive to buy but are cheap to earn. Then check search results for each target phrase: if Google shows mostly guides, write a guide, and if it shows service pages, build one.
How do SEO and PPC affect brand visibility and credibility?
Both channels put your name in front of searchers, but they build trust differently.
PPC gives you immediate, controlled visibility. You decide the message, and you can claim the top of the page for your most important terms. Many searchers recognise ads and treat them with some caution, so an ad is a strong prompt rather than a trust signal on its own. It does get your name seen, and repeated exposure helps people remember you.
SEO earns visibility that searchers often read as more credible, because the page was not bought. Ranking well for helpful content suggests you know the subject. Over time, a library of useful pages, good reviews and links from respected sites reinforce that impression. Credibility is slow to build and slow to lose.
The two also support each other. A searcher who sees your ad and then your organic listing on the same page sees you twice, which makes your brand look established. Strong organic content also tends to lift ad performance, because a credible site converts more of the clicks you pay for.
Accuracy underpins all of it. The ACCC states that advertising claims must be accurate, specific and provable. Vague “best in town” claims in ad copy or page titles invite both regulatory risk and reader scepticism. Plain, checkable claims about what you do and where you do it build more trust than superlatives.
If your goal is brand awareness in a crowded market, use PPC to appear straight away and SEO to make that appearance hold up when people click through and look closer.
What role do SEO and PPC play in the marketing funnel?
A funnel describes the path from first awareness to a paying customer, and each channel fits different stages.
Top of the funnel (awareness). SEO is strongest here. Informational content such as guides, checklists and explainers catches people who are still working out their problem. PPC can reach this stage too, but buying broad informational clicks is rarely cost-effective unless you are building an audience for later retargeting.
Middle of the funnel (consideration). Both channels contribute. Comparison pages and case-style content rank organically, while paid search captures people comparing providers. This is also where retargeting ads remind visitors who left without enquiring.
Bottom of the funnel (decision). PPC often dominates here, because high-intent searches such as “hire”, “quote” or “near me” convert well and justify paying for the click. A well-optimised service page ranking organically for the same terms is cheaper once it is established.
The practical lesson is to match spend to stage. If you only run PPC on bottom-funnel terms, you will harvest existing demand but never create new demand, and your cost per click may creep up as competitors bid for the same searchers. If you only run SEO, you may build awareness but miss urgent buyers while rankings develop.
Map each target keyword to a stage before you assign it a channel. Terms that signal readiness to buy go to PPC first and SEO second. Research-style terms go to SEO first. That one exercise prevents most budget mismatches and gives your reporting a clear logic.
How do SEO and PPC work with your other marketing channels?
Search rarely works alone. People see your Instagram post, hear about you from a friend, then search your name or your service. Your other channels create demand, and search captures it.
Here is how the pieces connect:
- Social media: social content builds awareness that later shows up as branded searches. Social audiences can also inform PPC targeting and ad creative.
- Email: your list is a place to send new SEO content and to retarget people who visited from an ad.
- Website design: both channels depend on a fast, mobile-friendly site with clear calls to action. Poor design wastes organic rankings and paid clicks alike, which is why business.gov.au lists website features alongside search marketing in its digital strategy advice.
- Photography and video: original images and short videos improve landing pages, ad extensions and the time visitors spend on your site.
- Offline marketing: print, events and referrals prompt searches. Make sure your business name and key services return a clear result when people look you up.
Use consistent messaging across all of these. If your ad promises one thing and your landing page says another, conversion drops and the paid click is wasted. If your social content uses different terms from your website, searchers may not connect them.
Share data between channels where you can. Questions customers ask on social or by email are a ready-made list of content topics for SEO. Ad copy that wins in PPC tests can sharpen your page titles and descriptions. Treat each channel as a source of insight for the others.
Finally, keep tracking joined up. If you can see that a customer first found you through an organic guide, later clicked an ad and finally booked after an email, you stop crediting only the last click and start funding the whole path.
How do local and global targeting change SEO and PPC?
The geography you serve changes how you run both channels.
For a local business, location is part of the query. People search “plumber near me” or “accountant in Ringwood”, and results lean on proximity. Local SEO focuses on a complete business profile, consistent name, address and phone details across the web, suburb or service-area pages, and reviews. We cover this through our SEO by suburb work.
Local PPC lets you target by radius, suburb or region, and exclude areas you do not serve. That control keeps spend from leaking to people who cannot become customers. Call extensions and location assets make it easy for nearby searchers to reach you.
For a business serving national or international customers, the picture shifts. SEO needs content that works beyond one place, and for several countries it may need separate pages with the right language and currency. PPC needs country-level targeting, bid adjustments by region and careful budget splits, because costs per click can differ greatly between markets.
A few cautions apply either way:
- Do not create dozens of near-identical location pages. Thin duplicates add little value and can hold your site back.
- Check that your ad location settings target people in your area, not only people showing interest in it, unless that is deliberate.
- Make sure claims about where you operate are true. Misleading statements about service areas can fall under the same ACCC rules as other advertising claims.
Start narrow. A tightly targeted local campaign and a handful of strong location pages usually beat a wide net, and you can expand once you know where leads come from.
What common mistakes should you avoid with SEO and PPC?
Each channel has its own traps. Knowing them saves months of wasted budget.
SEO pitfalls
- Expecting fast results: judging SEO after a few weeks, then abandoning it just before it would have paid off.
- Ignoring search intent: writing pages around a keyword without checking what searchers actually want.
- Neglecting technical basics: slow load times, broken pages and a poor mobile experience undercut good content.
- Chasing low-quality links: cheap link packages can do more harm than good.
- Letting content go stale: because SEO is continuous, pages that are never refreshed slip down the results.
PPC pitfalls
- Sending traffic to the homepage: a click that lands on a generic page rarely converts. Match each ad to a specific landing page.
- Skipping negative keywords: without them, budget drains into irrelevant searches.
- Set-and-forget management: campaigns drift as competitors and costs change.
- Over-trusting automation: automated campaign types like Performance Max need clear conversion goals and good data, or they optimise for the wrong outcome.
- Misleading ad copy: the ACCC has taken action over ads that implied a government link. Keep every claim truthful and provable.
Mistakes shared by both
- No conversion tracking, so you cannot tell what works.
- Running each channel in a silo, so learnings never cross over.
- Reporting on traffic instead of leads and revenue.
If you fix only one thing, make it tracking. Everything else, including keyword choice, budget and channel mix, depends on knowing which clicks turn into customers.
Why PPC should be your SEO research tool
Most advice on this topic tells you to pick a channel, or to “do both”. That is too vague to act on, and it ignores the best argument for sequencing them.
Our view is that SEO is the better long-term investment for most businesses with a decent sales cycle, but it is a poor first bet when you have no evidence about which keywords convert. Organic work is slow and cannot be reversed cheaply. Spending three months writing pages for terms that turn out not to produce leads is an expensive way to learn.
PPC is the cheap way to learn. A few weeks of focused ads tells you which phrases bring buyers, which offers resonate and which landing pages convert. Then you build SEO on proof instead of a hunch. In that sense paid search is research that happens to generate leads along the way.

What the conventional advice gets wrong is treating the two as rivals. The question is rarely “which is better”, but “which first, and what does the first teach the second”. Another thing worth saying plainly: SEO is not free, and PPC is not a trap. Both are priced differently, and mixing them up is what causes disappointment.
Prioritise this order. Fix tracking, run a small PPC test on your most valuable terms, then commit organic budget to the winners. Review regularly, and let the data move money between channels.
— MYBMC
Get a team that runs SEO and Google Ads as one plan
If you want help turning this into a working plan, we run an integrated approach that puts search budget where your data says it will pay back. Our SEO services and Google Ads management work together, so your paid results inform your organic strategy from day one.

Here is how you can start:
- Request an audit: we review your site, tracking and current search presence and tell you where the quickest wins are.
- Run a pilot: we test a focused paid campaign on your priority keywords before committing to a larger plan.
- Ask about pricing: pricing is not published on our site, so ask us for a quote that fits your goals.
- Book a discovery call: talk through your goals, timeline and budget with our team.
If you are ready, book your SEO and Google Ads audit with us and we will map out your initial plan.
FAQ
Is SEO dead now with AI?
No. AI features change how results are displayed, but people still search and websites still need to be found and trusted. Content that answers questions clearly and is kept up to date continues to be what search systems draw on, so the fundamentals of SEO still apply.
Is PPC just Google Ads?
No. Google Ads is the biggest PPC platform for search, and Business Victoria recommends focusing on it given Google’s share of Australian searches. Pay-per-click also exists on other search engines and on social platforms, but Google Ads is where most businesses start.
Is Google Ads considered SEO?
No. Google Ads is paid advertising, while SEO earns unpaid placement. Small business guidance describes paid search as appearing above organic results, and SEO as improving a site so it appears more often in unpaid searches.
What is replacing SEO?
Nothing is replacing it, but search is widening to include AI-generated answers alongside traditional results. That is why many businesses now pair classic SEO with AI search optimisation, so their content can be found and cited in both places.
Which should a new business with a small budget choose first?
Start with a small, tightly targeted PPC test if you need leads soon, and keep your website technically sound from the start. Once you know which keywords convert, put organic effort into those terms rather than guessing.
Sources
- Accc
- Business
- A starter’s guide to paid search ads | Business Victoria
- Reach Customers Across YouTube & Search – Google Ads